Before The Court
X
login

Recent questions tagged murder

Shubham bharti

asked 1 day ago in Criminal by Shubham bharti

What if you know that someone is going to murder another person but then too, you didn't inform police or anyone?

My friend was madly in love with his girlfriend. One day he came to know that his girlfriend was cheating on him. He turned insane and said that he would teach that girl a lesson. One day he went to her house and stabbed her. Later her friend told me that she was dead. I knew everything about his plan. Am I liable?

Shubham bharti

asked 2 days ago in Criminal by Shubham bharti

If minor is involved in a murder case with others, will he be liable equally as others criminals?

My son was threatened that if he didn’t help his seniors to leak the question paper they would torture him the entire year. He agreed to help them. While breaking in the staff room, the peon saw them and tried to stop them. Scared, one of his seniors hit the peon on his head. The peon died. Suddenly two teachers came and caught everyone. All of them are now under the trail of cheating and killing the peon. My son is a minor and he has never done such an act before. He was no where responsible for killing the peon. Would these work as mitigating factors?

Shubham bharti

asked 2 days ago in Criminal by Shubham bharti

What if someone has murder his/her father in extreme condition?

I went to my friend’s house for group study. Her father has been in bed for 10 years. Doctors said that there is no cure and she has to suffer that pain. When I went to her father’s room, her father was shouting in pain. She was distressed. Without thinking much, my friend went there and took out his oxygen mask. Her father died. What is the extent of her liability?

Shubham bharti

asked 2 days ago in Criminal by Shubham bharti

What if you saw some person is threating another person and later you discovered that deceased was killed?

I am a manager of a very famous hotel in Pune, Maharashtra. There was a diplomat who was staying at the hotel where I work. He asked for a room which was secluded from rest of the rooms. There is a very complicated procedure for providing such rooms but he was very powerful and I didn’t want to mess with him and hence I readily gave him the room. One night I was visiting his room to ask if he was comfortable. As soon as I reached there the door was ajar and the diplomat threatened a guy that he would kill him if his work was not done. I came back. Next day I found the same person killed at the backyard of the hotel where I work. The police carried out a thorough investigation but couldn’t find anything. I have no proof whether the diplomat killed the guy or not. Was I wrong by giving him the room readily? Am I liable?

Shubham bharti

asked 2 days ago in Criminal by Shubham bharti

What if any teacher has taught about it's subject and found that student are misusing that to murder someone?

I am a law teacher. One day I was teaching my students about murder under IPC. I told them the various possible cases which constitutes murder. I also taught them how murder was committed under some cases, and also how the person was not held liable due to various reasons. Whatever I taught them was in good faith. One of my students committed murder but due to lack of evidence, wasn’t held liable. The victim’s family sued me for abetting the boy for murdering their son. Being the teacher myself, I know the extent to which I am liable but I am really freaked out now! Please help me and tell me the extent to which I am liable!

Shubham bharti

asked 2 days ago in Criminal by Shubham bharti

What if somebody instigated me to kill another person. Will that person held liable for the same?

I was madly in love with a guy and we used to live together. One day he told me that there was a woman in his office who used to seduce him daily and even tried to molest him once. One day he came home crying and told me that he wants to get rid of her. She is his boss and he would lose his job if he complained about her. He instigated me to murder his boss and I followed through with the plan and later came to know that he was in relationship with her and it was nothing as he had told me. I know I have done wrong and deserve to be punished but he is also a wrongdoer. What can I do to teach him a lesson?

Shubham bharti

asked 2 days ago in Criminal by Shubham bharti

What if I have killed someone in condition where I need urgent money?

  • My husband lost his job. We were going through a bad time and all our relatives washed their hands off us. One day I was detected with third stage cancer. All our insurances had expired. One day the doctor demanded 20 lakhs for my first chemotherapy. My husband assured that he will try to get the money as soon as possible. After two days he came up with 20 lakhs. I asked him how he managed to get such a big amount. He said that he had some of his savings. That day in the evening the police came to our house and said that my husband has committed murder and arrested him. Later my husband told me that there was a woman in his office who was tortured by her husband and told my husband that if he poisons her husband she would give him the money. My husband went a night before to the lady’s house and peeped through the window of her hall and saw that her husband was beating her. The lady has worked with him for 10 years and he assures that the lady didn’t cook up anything. The doctor has said that I have very few days. I want to spend those few days with my husband. He said one day that he would start a new job and save as much as he could and open a trust for cancer patients. I agree that my husband has done a wrong act but he is not a murderer and he does not deserve to be punished the same way. I have heard about mitigating factors in law. How could it help me?

AnmolB

asked Oct 10 in Criminal by AnmolB

Can I be kept under police custody for investigation of an offence for more than 24 hours?

A murder took place in my neighborhood. The relatives of the deceased accused me of it. I was taken for investigation to the police station and I stayed there for more than 24 hours. Under what provisions do the officers have the right to keep me for so long?

AnmolB

asked Oct 10 in Criminal by AnmolB

Will I be bound to answer all the questions put forth if I was present in a train where a man was murdered?

I was traveling from Delhi to Mumbai in Rajdhani train. At 7 pm when the train stopped at Surat station, I saw a child exiting from one of the coaches and he had a bloody knife in his hand. When I entered the coach I saw an old man lying dead. The police reached the spot and began investigating me. Am I bound to answer all the questions put forth to me?

AnmolB

asked Oct 7 in Criminal by AnmolB

What should I do when I am a witness to an incident where my friend has been arrested on ground of murder?

My friend has always been distressed with his life. One day I didn’t see him the entire day. I even went to his house and everywhere he could possibly go. Suddenly I felt that he was so distressed maybe he should not take a step to hurt him. Even that thought made me shiver and I ran to suicide point. I went there and from down I saw my friend roaming there. I climbed the stairs and reached there. I saw he climbed the cliff with a cable around his ankle. As soon as I went there to stop him he already jumped. I ran to the cliff and saw that he was hanging there because of the cable. I helped him come up and saw the man who was working with the cables died due to electric shock. My friend was arrested on accounts of murder. What should I do?

AnmolB

asked Oct 7 in Criminal by AnmolB

What should I do if I know that a masseuse arrested on grounds of murder is innocent?

I go to a masseuse who is very experienced. One day I was resting when she was massaging a woman in front of me. The lady told her to massage her in middle of her waist. As soon as the masseuse did that she started breathing heavily and died in few seconds. The masseuse was arrested on grounds of murder. I have seen the entire thing and it was no fault of hers. The lady didn’t tell her about something extraordinary or critical about that part. What should I do?

AnmolB

asked Oct 7 in Criminal by AnmolB

What should I do when my friend was arrested on grounds of murder for taking away the oxygen mask of his sick mother?

I went to my friend’s house for group study. His mother has been in bed for 10 years without any cure. While we were studying she told me that her mom has been in deep pain for the past one week. Doctors said that there is no cure and she has to suffer that pain. When I went to her mother’s room, her mom was shouting in pain. She was distressed. Without thinking much, my friend went there and took out her oxygen mask. Her mom died. She was arrested on accounts of murder. I think what she did was not wrong and no one has clue what she was going through. What should I do?

AnmolB

asked Oct 7 in Criminal by AnmolB

What should I do to protect my senior who is being falsely accused by the Superintendent?

I am sub police inspector. We were at our police station at around 10 pm where a man said that he was threatened by three armed man and needed immediate help. I along with my senior who is the Police Inspector and also an Encounter Specialist went for his rescue. We reached the man’s place and after giving few warnings we barged in. The assailants started attacking us and in an aid to protect the person who filed the complaint and also to protect ourselves we started shooting and sir had shot 2 out of 3 assailants and one was taken to the hospital by sir and me in critical situation where he succumbed to his injuries. Our SP did not have very good relations with sir and she took the case all by herself and depicted a picture stating that the whole incident was planned by sir and the person who complained. Sir was charged under sections 302 for murder, 120 (B) criminal conspiracy and 166 for disobeying the law as public servant. I know that sir is an incredible police officer and he could have done nothing. What can I do?

AnmolB

asked Oct 7 in Criminal by AnmolB

Will my husband be liable for the death of a woman after he denied to rape her on the instructions of psychopaths?

There were a bunch of psychopaths who kidnapped my husband. While he was in their custody, they kidnapped another woman and told my husband to rape that woman just for their fun. My husband did not agree. They threatened that they would kill the lady. They killed the lady. Is my husband liable?

AnmolB

asked Oct 4 in Criminal by AnmolB

What will be the extent of my friend's liability who pulled the plug on her father to relieve him of his endless pain?

I went to my friend’s house for group study. Her father has been in bed for 10 years. Doctors said that there is no cure and he has to suffer that pain. When I went to her father’s room, her father was shouting in pain. She was distressed. Without thinking much, my friend went there and took out his oxygen mask. Her father died. What is the extent of her liability?

AnmolB

asked Oct 4 in Criminal by AnmolB

Will I be liable if I gave a secluded room to a powerful man who might be involved in murdering someone?

I am a manager of a very famous hotel in Pune, Maharashtra. There was a diplomat who was staying at the hotel where I work. He asked for a room which was secluded from rest of the rooms. There is a very complicated procedure for providing such rooms but he was very powerful and I didn’t want to mess with him and hence I readily gave him the room. One night I was visiting his room to ask if he was comfortable. As soon as I reached there the door was ajar and the diplomat threatened a guy that he would kill him if his work was not done. I came back. Next day I found the same person killed at the backyard of the hotel where I work. The police carried out a thorough investigation but couldn’t find anything. I have no proof whether the diplomat killed the guy or not. Was I wrong by giving him the room readily? Am I liable?

AnmolB

asked Oct 4 in Criminal by AnmolB

What will be our liability if I instigated my wife to kill our neighbor but she ended up killing his identical twin?

My wife and I were happily married. My wife was raped by my neighbor. She was depressed. If I wanted I could have taught him a very good lesson but I wanted my wife to get her confidence back and take her own revenge. I worked on that daily. One day she went to his home with a knife and stabbed him. Later on we came to know that it was his identical twin that she had killed. It was a genuine mistake. She was held liable for murder and I for abetting her to do so. Till what extent are we liable?

AnmolB

asked Oct 4 in Criminal by AnmolB

Will I be liable if the girl I have been reluctantly living with murdered another girl I fell in love with?

I am living with a girl. We are not married. I wasn’t comfortable living with her and I told her many times that we should break up. She used to threaten me that she would commit suicide. I fell in love with another girl and I thought adultery won’t be a crime in case of a live-in relationship. She came to know about it and she went and murdered the girl. Would I be liable?

AnmolB

asked Sep 30 in Criminal by AnmolB

What should I do if I suspect my son to be involved in the circumstances that led to the death of my daughter in law?

My son and daughter-in law live in USA. My daughter in law was pregnant with her third child. I have two granddaughters who are very close to me. I saw that day that he was trying to instigate his wife that I want a grandson and that I am very unhappy that she has failed to give me one. I tried to clarify that the claims made by my son to her were not true and she said that they were planning a third child. As soon as I went to USA for her delivery I saw a change in behavior of my son. I saw the papers of a house which he was planning to buy at Canada with the sign of some other women. I asked him about it and he said that those papers belong to his work and tried to keep my attention away from the issue. Next morning I saw my daughter in law lying on the floor with the vein of her right arm bleeding. I suspect my son into this and he deserves to be punished. What should I do?

AnmolB

asked Sep 30 in Criminal by AnmolB

What should I do if I suspect my mother involved in the circumstances leading to the death of my wife?

My wife was pregnant with her third child. We live in USA. We have two daughters. It was her 8th month and the gynecologist told us that it was a girl. My mother always told me that she always wanted a grandson and her daughter in law failed to give her one. As soon as she stepped into her 9th month my mother came to our place. Next morning I saw my wife lying on the floor with the vein of her right arm bleeding. She was dead. We were married for the past 6 years and there was no reason for her to commit suicide. I suspect my mother to be involved in this. I feel either she abetted her to commit suicide or killed her. What should I do?

...